2:47 p.m.
Dear Roll-out team,
I drafted a short interview guideline for the interviews with our PPs regarding the use of
MatWerk solutions.
You find it attached. Please review it.
Thank you in advance
Best regards,
Julia
Dr. Julia Mohrbacher
Projekt NFDI-MatWerk, https://nfdi-matwerk.de
Task Area Strategy Development
julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de
Tel.: 0761/20395181
Follow us on LinkedIn

4:37 p.m.
Hi,
thanks a lot for the draft!
I added some suggestions and some comments.
Cheers!
erik

On 10. Sep 2024, at 14:47, Julia Mohrbacher
<julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de> wrote:
Dear Roll-out team,
I drafted a short interview guideline for the interviews with our PPs regarding the use
of MatWerk solutions.
You find it attached. Please review it.
Thank you in advance
Best regards,
Julia
<20240910_Interview guideline_draft JM.docx>
Dr. Julia Mohrbacher
Projekt NFDI-MatWerk, https://nfdi-matwerk.de
Task Area Strategy Development
julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de
Tel.: 0761/20395181
Follow us on LinkedIn
<image004.png>
---
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Erik Bitzek
Head of ‘Microstructure & Mechanics’ Group
Max Planck Institute for Sustainable Materials
Computational Materials Design
Web: https://www.mpie.de/4626599/Microstructure_Mechanics
Tel: +49 (0)211/6792-297
e.bitzek(a)mpie.de
5:07 p.m.
Dear all,
I would prefer a different approach and would like to discuss it with you tomorrow in our
meeting.
Let us send questionnaires to the interview partners in advance. I have an Excel
spreadsheet in my head, with one column listing all the available software solutions
(we'll have to discuss which ones tomorrow, only from this current, incomplete
list<https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/collection/software-solutions> or more?).
Next to this are other columns containing the questions from Julia's file:
* Which of these software solutions are you using in your PP?
* Which of these software solutions are you using in other contexts?
* Please describe within 1-2 sentences how the used solutions from NFDI-MatWerk helped
with your work?
* Did your work get easier/better/faster using this specific MatWerk solution? Can you
elaborate briefly on this?
* Have you ever tried to use other software solutions from this list? If yes, please
let us know why you are not using it anymore?
Additionally, we could ask in advance: what do you would need, to use more of our software
tools? Are there missing solutions for your specific research field?
In the interview itself, we then can be faster and could ask for more details and specific
needs of the person.
That was my idea so far. However, based on my feedback on the website and the solutions
website so far, there may be other aspects to consider, so I would suggest finalising this
list of questions at tomorrow's meeting.
Best regards,
Katharina
Von: Bitzek, Erik <e.bitzek(a)mpie.de>
Datum: Mittwoch, 11. September 2024 um 08:22
An: Julia Mohrbacher <julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de>
Cc: nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout(a)lists.nfdi.de <nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout(a)lists.nfdi.de>,
Zimmermann, Martina <martina.zimmermann(a)iws.fraunhofer.de>, Dr. Stefan Klein
<stefan.klein(a)dgm.de>
Betreff: [Nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout] Re: Draft for interview guideline - please review
Hi,
thanks a lot for the draft!
I added some suggestions and some comments.
Cheers!
erik
On 10. Sep 2024, at 14:47, Julia Mohrbacher <julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de>
wrote:
Dear Roll-out team,
I drafted a short interview guideline for the interviews with our PPs regarding the use of
MatWerk solutions.
You find it attached. Please review it.
Thank you in advance
Best regards,
Julia
<20240910_Interview guideline_draft JM.docx>
Dr. Julia Mohrbacher
Projekt NFDI-MatWerk, https://nfdi-matwerk.de
Task Area Strategy Development
julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de
Tel.: 0761/20395181
Follow us on LinkedIn
<image004.png>
---
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Erik Bitzek
Head of ‘Microstructure & Mechanics’ Group
Max Planck Institute for Sustainable Materials
Computational Materials Design
Web: https://www.mpie.de/4626599/Microstructure_Mechanics
Tel: +49 (0)211/6792-297
e.bitzek(a)mpie.de
5:27 p.m.
Hi,
Providing the list ahead of time is a good idea!
Regarding the list, we already had some discussions.
I suggest excluding the stuff not developed by / not part of NFDI-MatWerk,
e.g. KADI4Mat. On the other hand, I didn’t see OpenBis, which I thought was being pushed
by NFDI-MatWerk.
An important factor is who is interviewed / who gets to provide input for the list.
An SFB member, even the spokesperson, will not know what >12 project partners are using
individually, but I think we will need this level of detail.
I suggest also to ask in which IUCs the PPs are using these solutions,
as well as which solutions they have provided input for development.
So far, my two cents. I am at a symposium tomorrow and will, therefore, not be able to
join your discussion.
Thanks!
Erik
On 11. Sep 2024, at 17:07, Katharina Bollmann
<katharina.bollmann(a)dgm.de> wrote:
Dear all,
I would prefer a different approach and would like to discuss it with you tomorrow in our
meeting.
Let us send questionnaires to the interview partners in advance. I have an Excel
spreadsheet in my head, with one column listing all the available software solutions
(we'll have to discuss which ones tomorrow, only from this current, incomplete list
<https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/collection/software-solutions> or more?). Next to
this are other columns containing the questions from Julia's file:
Which of these software solutions are you using in your PP?
Which of these software solutions are you using in other contexts?
Please describe within 1-2 sentences how the used solutions from NFDI-MatWerk helped with
your work?
Did your work get easier/better/faster using this specific MatWerk solution? Can you
elaborate briefly on this?
Have you ever tried to use other software solutions from this list? If yes, please let us
know why you are not using it anymore?
Additionally, we could ask in advance: what do you would need, to use more of our
software tools? Are there missing solutions for your specific research field?
In the interview itself, we then can be faster and could ask for more details and
specific needs of the person.
That was my idea so far. However, based on my feedback on the website and the solutions
website so far, there may be other aspects to consider, so I would suggest finalising this
list of questions at tomorrow's meeting.
Best regards,
Katharina
Von: Bitzek, Erik <e.bitzek(a)mpie.de <mailto:e.bitzek@mpie.de>>
Datum: Mittwoch, 11. September 2024 um 08:22
An: Julia Mohrbacher <julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de
<mailto:julia.mohrbacher@imtek.uni-freiburg.de>>
Cc: nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout(a)lists.nfdi.de
<mailto:nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout@lists.nfdi.de>
<nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout(a)lists.nfdi.de
<mailto:nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout@lists.nfdi.de>>, Zimmermann, Martina
<martina.zimmermann(a)iws.fraunhofer.de
<mailto:martina.zimmermann@iws.fraunhofer.de>>, Dr. Stefan Klein
<stefan.klein(a)dgm.de <mailto:stefan.klein@dgm.de>>
Betreff: [Nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout] Re: Draft for interview guideline - please review
Hi,
thanks a lot for the draft!
I added some suggestions and some comments.
Cheers!
erik
On 10. Sep 2024, at 14:47, Julia Mohrbacher <julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de
<mailto:julia.mohrbacher@imtek.uni-freiburg.de>> wrote:
Dear Roll-out team,
I drafted a short interview guideline for the interviews with our PPs regarding the use
of MatWerk solutions.
You find it attached. Please review it.
Thank you in advance
Best regards,
Julia
<20240910_Interview guideline_draft JM.docx>
Dr. Julia Mohrbacher
Projekt NFDI-MatWerk, https://nfdi-matwerk.de <https://nfdi-matwerk.de/>
Task Area Strategy Development
julia.mohrbacher(a)imtek.uni-freiburg.de
<mailto:julia.mohrbacher@imtek.uni-freiburg.de>
Tel.: 0761/20395181
Follow us on LinkedIn
<image004.png>
---
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Erik Bitzek
Head of ‘Microstructure & Mechanics’ Group
Max Planck Institute for Sustainable Materials
Computational Materials Design
Web: https://www.mpie.de/4626599/Microstructure_Mechanics
Tel: +49 (0)211/6792-297
e.bitzek(a)mpie.de <mailto:e.bitzek@mpie.de>
---
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Erik Bitzek
Head of ‘Microstructure & Mechanics’ Group
Max Planck Institute for Sustainable Materials
Computational Materials Design
Web: https://www.mpie.de/4626599/Microstructure_Mechanics
Tel: +49 (0)211/6792-297
e.bitzek(a)mpie.de
101
days inactive
102
days old
nfdi-matwerk_ag_rollout@lists.nfdi.de
3 comments
3 participants
participants (3)
-
Bitzek, Erik -
Julia Mohrbacher -
Katharina Bollmann